Nikki’s Picks

Products Recommended

La Gritona Tequila Reposado

La Gritona Tequila Reposado

La Gritona is what I consider to be the best middle-ground tequila out there. Of course, there will always be something better; but in terms of cost and versatility, this one is hard to beat. Although it’s considered a reposado, it does tread the line between that and a blanco; it’s light enough to be enjoyed by those who don’t prefer barrel-aged agave and nuanced enough to also be appreciated by those that do. The distillery is among the only ones in Jalisco owned by a woman; Melly Barajas, who is a master distiller. Melly employs a small staff of other local women who assist her in this operation to make awesome tequila with attention to detail and a passion for the craft.

View Product

Two Chicks Gin, Apple, and Cucumber Gimlet

Two Chicks Gin, Apple, and Cucumber Gimlet

If you are looking for a traditional, by-the-book Gimlet, this may not be the drink for you. However, if you are looking for something new, refreshing, and tasty as hell, then I present to you the Two Chicks’s Sparkling Apple Gimlet! Green apple skin, the best part of biting into a cucumber, and a twist of lime! This company is owned and operated by two women (if the name didn’t already give that away) who set out to achieve delicious, pre-made cocktails that inspire connection and positive conversation, as all tasty drinks should!

View Product

Weingut Fuchs und Hase Vol.2

Weingut Fuchs und Hase Vol.2

I will admit, when I first grabbed this bottle off the shelf it was because I thought it was pretty (alas, my fatal flaw). However, I do always like to get a second opinion on things like this so I’m not just being hoodwinked by the pretty flowers; and to provide a second opinion to YOU if you're also considering the nice-looking foliage, I’m pleased to say this is also an absolutely delicious wine! It is a pétillant naturel with the perfect amount of sparkle and primarily composed of Gruner Veltliner and Muskateller. Although each volume of this wine is slightly different in terms of varietals, the care and dedication put into them remains the same.

View Product

Gran Agave Ghost Edition Tequila

Gran Agave Ghost Edition Tequila

I began fawning over this tequila long ago but quickly learned it had yet to become available here. After waiting for another Halloween to arrive, the coveted Ghost was finally obtainable in BayTowne’s neck of the woods. And it was worth the wait — a really, surprisingly delightful reposado that’s delicate and balanced. Although it’s common to find ornate, highly stylized bottles over-compensating for lack of quality inside, Gran Agave’s Ghost Edition is a delicious exception!

View Product


Drew's Picks

Products Recommended

Crown Royal Peach Tea Canned Cocktails

Crown Royal Peach Tea Canned Cocktails

Canned cocktails. No shame. The delicious fruitiness of ripe peach at the beach! Balanced bitterness from the tea with a deserved kick down-the-backside on the finish. I will drink 30 of these every day.

View Product

Moroki Brewery – Tae No Hana “Sublime Beauty” Arabashiri Kimoto Muroka Nama Junmai Genshu

Moroki Brewery – Tae No Hana “Sublime Beauty” Arabashiri Kimoto Muroka Nama Junmai Genshu

Quickly transcribed, this is a rough press, partial wild yeast started, non-charcoal filtered, unpasteurized, undiluted, pure rice sake. What this translates to is a SUPER RICH, uber-textural, complex, umami-laden, powerful, precise sake. A true standout in an era dominated by delicate Ginjo.

View Product

Brooklyn Kura “Catskills” Junmai Nama Chozo Daiginjo

Brooklyn Kura “Catskills” Junmai Nama Chozo Daiginjo

The quick version: pure rice sake, once pasteurized, and rice milled to 50%. Translated: an elegant, floral, super smooth, delightfully mineral, and pure sake. Think Mosel Riesling or Sancerre. Made with water from the Catskills, Brooklyn Kura’s second ever Daiginjo is a banger. One of the best sakes I’ve ever tasted and from a Brewery I am ever more excited about.

View Product

2019 Sandhi Central Coast Chardonnay

2019 Sandhi Central Coast Chardonnay

"WHOA. I’m just going to say it – this guy rocks! I’m looking at all these other Chardonnay’s sitting on the shelf, and this is the one doing all the rocking. Am I right?" -Russ Hanneman

View Product


Lucas Picks

Products Recommended

hampden great house 2022 at baytowne wine & spirits

Hampden Great House 2022

Hampden Great House 2022

Hampden Estate is deeply respected by rum lovers, known for complex and unctuous, even riotous, fruit notes and great hogo ‘funk.’ We have their 2022 Great House, a particularly delicious expression.
Nose: Overripe mango, rice crispy treat, and cinnamon-cooked guava Palate: Cooked and luxuriant, with bbq pineapple, truffle butter, and grilled guava with marshmallow sauce
Finish: Butter-sauteed mango, honey-roasted almonds, and honey nut cereal with almond milk and dried pineapple.
An authentically premium rum well worth its price.

View Product

Hamilton 151

Hamilton 151

With no added coloring or sweetening, Hamilton 151 bridges an impressive gap as both an integral tiki ingredient, namely Jet Pilots or Zombies, and a pour one could sip neat, albeit carefully. Dark brown sugar and a touch of pomegranate on the nose shifts into dark roast coffee and a mango/cherry jam on the palate. The bold molasses character rounds the finish to notes of cooked cherries, black strap molasses, and chocolate vanilla twist ice cream. This beautifully bold rum will bring its delicious heft wherever applied.

View Product

Power's Three Swallow

Power's Three Swallow

I came to Powers Three Swallow in talking with an Irish whiskey author about its profile. When he mentioned banana-bread forward, I was in. This is a deliciously fruity but wonderfully complex single pot still. I would say banana, lemon, and vanilla, in that order of magnitude, are the summative notes of this dram. As a non-chill filtered single pot still for under sixty dollars, with that tasty a profile, it’s a genuine steal — one I’d like to see you get away with.

View Product

Killowen Txakolina Acacia Cask 10 Yr. Old Blended Irish Whiskey

Killowen Txakolina Acacia Cask 10 Yr. Old Blended Irish Whiskey

James Pellingra, former GM of BayTowne, drew this to my attention, and I appreciate that he did. Master distiller Brendan Carty took 10-year-old blended Irish whiskey and secondarily matured it in acacia txakolina wine casks from Basque. It starts with apple tart, Demerara sugar, and clove on the nose. The palate moves to cooked pear, grain bar, and a prominent golden raisin note. The finish brings pear crustada and brown sugar. I can’t wait to see what Killowen comes out with next.

View Product


Andy’s Picks

Products Recommended

Sidebar Zinfandel, Mokelumne River

Sidebar Zinfandel, Mokelumne River

This 14.5% Zinfandel will not let you down. The Smokey, spicy wine wraps potent blackberry flavors in black pepper, beef, and wood smoke for a dark delicious effect. This is full body, moderately tannic and nicely concentrated.

View Product

Quattro Mani Falaghina del Sannio

Quattro Mani Falaghina del Sannio

This southern Italian white is very similar to a lightly oaked chard. Pairs well with any spicy dish, shell fish, or even vegetarian food. A great $10 value. Bright acidity, pale straw color, medium light body. Lemons, apricot with a hint of elderflower. Oh my. Buy two, it goes fast.

View Product


John's Picks

Products Recommended

La Forge Sauvignon Blanc 2019

La Forge Sauvignon Blanc 2019

Citrus and grapefruit with lemongrass and honeydew melon. Crisp finish with some texture. This wine is better than the Rolling Stones!

View Product


Bob’s Picks

Products Recommended

Rumming Head Start

Rumming Head Start

Distilled and bottled in Ipswich, Mass our Single Cask Store Pick from Privateer Rum Distillery is rum that was aged for over 2 years and can easily be poured for your Bourbon sipping friends. Don’t tell them it’s Rum until they ask about it. Forget what you think you know about rum and try this. It is unsweetened and has no additives. What you see and taste is what came out of the oak cask.

View Product

1792 Single Barrel

1792 Single Barrel

Although this is not a store pick it is a true single Barrel bourbon that comes from the Barton 1792 Distillery in Bardstown, KY. With sweet notes of butterscotch and caramel this $39 bottle in an incredible value and could easily be a daily sipper or something to break out for that next hunting weekend. The unique bottle definitely makes it stand out in a crowd.  


Sam's Picks

Products Recommended

Cote Mas Rouge

Cote Mas Rouge

Jean-Claude Mas has blazed the trail for premium winemaking in the Languedoc region of the South of France. Since taking the helm of the centuries-old Domaines Paul Mas in 2000, his driving mission has been to prioritize sourcing the highest-quality grapes to craft wines of authenticity and refinement, and to craft superior wines with a modern, New-World flair. The Syrah and Grenache blend has medium body with medium acidity and a smooth-mouth feel. Jean-Claude Mas’s 1 liter bottle of Cote Mas Rouge conveys the heritage, beauty, and unique terroir of this southern French region. It is a delicious and accessible wine at a very attractive price point.

View Product

Arette Tequila

Arette Tequila

Arette Tequila is made in the Jalisco region of Mexico. It is certified ADDITIVE-FREE! Its floral and fruity notes give it an easy finish. Enjoy Arette with a wedge of lime or in any of your favorite cocktails. Arette is an enjoyable tequila on its own — uncommon for a tequila in this price range!

View Product


Justin's Picks

Products Recommended

Sottimano “Mate” 2020

Sottimano “Mate” 2020

A light and dry Brachetto hailing from Northern Italy. This is my stranded on a desert island wine. Drink this anytime with anything. Flowers and fresh fruits on the nose that soften on the palate for a smooth finish. For those new to Italian wines, this is a perfect introduction. Buy this in bulk because it will go by fast!

View Product

Tommyrotter American Gin

Tommyrotter American Gin

As the American Gin scene has taken off, Tommyrotter out of Buffalo, NY has impressed me. This floral and citrusy gin is a true delight. Coming in at 84 proof, it is very approachable and easy to sip straight and brings the flavor when mixed with tonic. I always love to see local brands with great product; this is one of them.

View Product


There are no staff picks at this time.

We invite you to visit our store! For more information or to speak with our staff, submit a contact form.

Contact Us